Mintos
Recommended4.0/5
Seven of my loan originators failed and I still came out ahead, which is why it's where I'd point serious money first.
8–12% €50 min MiFID II Buyback
P2P lending in Italy works through Europe's cross-border platforms. Every platform in this ranking accepts Italian investors. The platforms operate EU-wide, most of them across the whole EEA. We've scored all 21 on the same four dimensions we apply everywhere, with our own money on the top picks. Platforms we rate Not recommended stay in the ranking, with a link that only names the platform.
All 21 P2P lending platforms in this ranking accept investors from Italy. The loans span consumer, business, real-estate, and agricultural lending. Minimum investments start at €1 and run to €1,000. Advertised returns range from 6% to 16% per year. 11 of the 21 hold a MiFID II or ECSP licence, and the other 10 operate unregulated. The oldest platform here has taken investor money since 2014, the newest since 2023.
This is the same ranking that anchors our European P2P platform ranking. Availability doesn't change the verdicts. Every verified sign-up bonus is listed in the P2P bonus overview, and every market we cover is in P2P lending by country.
4.0/5
Seven of my loan originators failed and I still came out ahead, which is why it's where I'd point serious money first.
8–12% €50 min MiFID II Buyback
3.8/5
Delivers exactly the 6% it advertises, with zero effort required.
Up to 6% €1 min Unregulated None
3.4/5
Licensed, fee-free notes that pay their coupons. The term filter decides your rate.
9–13% €50 min MiFID II Buyback
3.3/5
InRento registers each mortgage for its investors, as their representative. No InRento mortgage had been enforced by October 2026, and two Polish loans went into recovery that autumn.
9.25–11.5% €500 min ECSP Mortgage
3.3/5
Farm loans, mostly against land or machinery, where defaults have become years, not losses.
9–12% €50 min ECSP Mortgage
3.1/5
Buybacks work while its loan originators can pay, but one 2022 default is still only partly repaid.
7–15% €10 min Unregulated Buyback
3.0/5
Coupons paid to the cent under a Latvian licence, but every note funds Nectaro's own DYNINNO group, whose parent company is the largest borrower.
10–14% €50 min MiFID II Buyback
3.0/5
Its loan originators repaid their war-hit loans in full, but PeerBerry couldn't keep my portfolio invested.
8.5–10% €10 min Unregulated Buyback
3.0/5
Licensed in Latvia, but every new security is repaid by one Polish card company.
6–12% €1 min MiFID II None
2.8/5
No reported freeze since its 2017 launch, on a group with $4.25M of equity against $82.8M owed to investors at the end of 2024.
8–10.5% €10 min Unregulated Buyback
2.7/5
Pays exactly its advertised rate, but every claim comes from one lending group, with no regulator or buyback behind it.
7.5–10.52% €10 min Unregulated None
2.6/5
Publishes its default figures, and they show 11.19% of its loans defaulting in an average year.
11–15% €100 min ECSP Mortgage
2.6/5
First-rank mortgages under a Bank of Lithuania licence, but a €1,000 ticket earns each loan's lowest rate and the only loan marked late sits beside a 0% default counter.
7.5–10.5% €1,000 min ECSP Mortgage
2.3/5
Creditstar's group guarantee backs its loans' buyback, but most loans on offer sit outside the licence and the top rates demand multi-year lock-ins.
Up to 15% €10 min ECSP Buyback
2.0/5
Each loan's assignment agreement is readable, but no auditor checks the platform's own accounts. Its founders own the loan originators behind most of the money on offer.
7–12% €10 min Unregulated Buyback
1.6/5
Licensed in Latvia, but two-thirds of its book funds one forest fund and its sister fund, and Flow's early exit is a request the issuer may refuse.
9–15% €10 min MiFID II Collateral
1.5/5
Every loan comes from companies Hive5 places in its own group, and the group's audited accounts carry a going-concern warning.
13–16% €10 min Unregulated Buyback
1.3/5
About two-thirds of the money out on loan was late or in recovery in October 2026, and the secondary market Estateguru closed in August had no announced reopening by November.
8–11% €50 min ECSP Mortgage
1.3/5
Every loan originator belongs to the group Lonvest calls its own, none shows audited accounts, and no published contract contains the "group guarantee" Lonvest markets.
9–13% €50 min Unregulated None
1.3/5
Its own terms say investor funds aren't privileged if the platform fails.
12–15% €50 min Unregulated Collateral
1.0/5
Double-digit rates, almost all of the money with one Fingular loan originator, and deposits unavailable for more than 11 weeks in 2026.
Up to 14.5% €10 min Unregulated Buyback
Italy has an active domestic platform scene, and it spans property, green-energy, and consumer lending. Trusters, part of the CrowdFundMe group, funds short-term property deals. Ener2Crowd channels retail money into green-energy projects, through both loans and equity stakes. Prestiamoci matches private lenders with Italian personal loans, and handles the collection work on them. Soisy merged into Compass Banca in January 2024, and its services were permanently discontinued. Rendimento Etico, a property-lending platform, has asked CONSOB to cancel its crowdfunding registration and is moving its investors’ positions to EvenFi, a Spanish-regulated crowdlending platform.
None of Italy’s platforms has been through our review process yet, and the ranking carries only platforms we have reviewed. Every cross-border platform in it accepts Italian investors, under home-country rules. The three strongest are Mintos, Go & Grow, and VIAINVEST.
The platforms in this ranking operate in euros, and Italy is in the eurozone. Funding an account is an ordinary SEPA transfer from a Italian bank, with no currency conversion anywhere in the chain.
Returns arrive in euros too, so what you see in this ranking is what you measure at home. The exchange-rate exposure that non-euro investors carry doesn't apply.
Italy licenses its domestic platforms through CONSOB under the EU crowdfunding regime — Trusters and Ener2Crowd both hold that authorisation — and cross-border platforms don’t need an Italian one. A platform licensed under MiFID II or the EU crowdfunding regime answers to its home-country regulator, and that licence passports across the EU. CONSOB licenses none of the platforms in this ranking, and neither does the Bank of Italy, whose register of financial intermediaries covers Prestiamoci instead.
11 of the 21 hold a MiFID II or ECSP licence, and crowdfunding licences can be checked in ESMA's register. The other 10 operate unregulated, which our Safety dimension prices in.
P2P investments sit outside the €100,000 bank deposit guarantee, and no scheme anywhere covers loans that default. The 5 MiFID II platforms in this ranking (Mintos, VIAINVEST, Nectaro, TWINO, and Debitum) are members of national investor compensation schemes under EU Directive 97/9/EC, which pay up to €20,000 if the firm itself fails to return your instruments or cash. An ECSP licence brings conduct rules but no compensation scheme, and the unregulated platforms carry neither.
Italian tax residents pay progressive income tax on interest from loans made or bought through the platforms in this ranking, at 23% up to €28,000, 33% to €50,000, and 43% above, plus regional and municipal add-ons, per the Agenzia delle Entrate. A flat 26% on P2P interest exists in Italian law, but only a platform run by an intermediary authorised by the Bank of Italy can apply it as a withholding at source. The platforms in this ranking sit abroad, outside that regime, so loan interest goes into the annual tax return at the full rates. Interest on notes, the securities some platforms sell instead of loans, may instead fall under Italy’s 26% tax on foreign securities income, and the Agenzia’s P2P rulings cover loans, not notes, so confirm their treatment with the Agenzia or an adviser.
13 of the 21 platforms in this ranking withhold nothing at their end either, so the Italian tax is settled entirely through the return. Accounts on foreign platforms are also declared as foreign financial assets in the return’s monitoring section, per the Agenzia delle Entrate’s guidance on platforms outside the Italian regime. Holdings you can resell, on a platform’s secondary market or as notes, also owe Italy’s 0.2% tax on foreign financial assets, at their nominal value. Where tax is withheld abroad, by a platform or by a borrower or loan originator in its own country, Italy credits tax withheld on loan interest against the Italian tax on the same income. Notes taxed under the 26% regime earn no credit for tax withheld abroad. The per-platform withholding row sits in each review’s fee table.
Savings-style products that pay their return as the price at which they buy back the loan claims you hold may be taxed differently, so check that treatment with the Agenzia delle Entrate or an adviser.